Italy grapples with its patriarchal history as femicide cases shock the nation

CNN

By Barbie Latza Nadeau and Antonia Mortensen, CNN

(CNN) — Some are stabbed, some are shot, some are strangled. However all the ladies killed by femicide in Italy have one factor in widespread: they knew their killers.

Greater than 100 girls had been killed in 2023. The time period ‘femicide’ – which is often when a girl is killed by a present or former companion – grew to become so topical an Italian encyclopedia named it as its phrase of the yr in 2023.

Italy may need a feminine prime minister, however she makes some extent of not figuring out herself as a feminist.

The nation solely criminalized crimes of ardour in 1981, and the judicial system nonetheless usually provides lighter sentences to male killers if their wives had been untrue.

In a infamous case in 2020, 80-year-old Antonio Gozzini was cleared of bludgeoning to loss of life his 62-year-old spouse, Cristina Maioli with a rolling pin whereas she slept after which slicing her throat and slicing up her legs as a result of the courtroom stated he suffered a “raptus” or delirious jealousy over his spouse’s job at an area college. Gozzini stays free at the moment.

The prevalence of home violence in Italy is fed by societal failures, says Lorella Zanardo, an activist, educator and documentary filmmaker.

Zanardo’s 2009 documentary “Il Corpo delle Donne” or “Girls’s Our bodies,” about sexism in Italian private and non-private tv, began a nationwide dialog concerning the hyperlink between sexism, sexual assault and gender equality.

Whereas Italy doesn’t have Europe’s highest charge of home violence, it’s among the many lowest ranked in Europe when it comes to gender equality.

In 2023 Italy dropped within the rankings from the earlier yr based mostly on components like growing wage disparity, which makes it tougher for girls to depart marriages as a result of they can’t assist themselves.

“Italy has been a rustic of patriarchy for a lot of, a few years, nevertheless it’s additionally a rustic of obscure as a result of within the 70s probably the most necessary and profitable girls’s motion was Italian,” Zanardo stated.

“I’ve requested myself what occurred after this motion. It’s tough to clarify however this motion was very political [and] had a really clear political connotation.”

A part of the issue with having a feminist motion so carefully tied to politics is that it turns into divisive.

In Italy, the feminist motion was largely pushed by the left, which meant that those that supported right-leaning events, together with present Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, have distanced themselves from feminism completely.

“We now have a girl prime minister, however she’s fully in opposition to it,” Zanardo stated, including that Meloni has even chosen to make use of the masculine article in entrance of the Italian phrase ‘prime minister’ somewhat than embracing the truth that Italy has one of many world’s few feminine leaders.

“She pretends to be referred to as ‘il’ prime minister like a person and I feel that a lady like her could possibly be an activist additionally in language by displaying to youthful generations that leaders will be girls,” Zanardo stated.

Meloni’s workplace didn’t reply to a request for touch upon the explanation behind the use of the male article in entrance of her title.

Feminist actions have been profitable autos to drive better equality internationally. The Council of Europe says, “On the whole, feminism will be seen as a motion to place an finish to sexism, sexist exploitation, and oppression and to realize full gender equality in legislation and in follow.”

And it’s feminist actions which can be doing probably the most to assist Italian victims of abuse.

CADMI is a shelter and useful resource heart for abused girls in Milan that has rescued 600 girls from abusive conditions within the final yr.

The middle was began by Italy’s Union of Girls, which is a left-leaning anti-fascist feminist group that opened the middle to offer girls a lifeline.

Cristina Carelli, who runs the middle, advised CNN they work on rehabilitation and re-education to empower the ladies to evolve from victims to survivors, and to turn into financially unbiased. They’ve helped assist greater than 36,000 girls since they opened the doorways in 1986, Carelli says. Creating relationships constructed on belief is essential to empowerment, however their work hasn’t at all times been straightforward.

Once they began, folks distrusted them, Carelli says.

“They had been very younger, however they hadn’t acknowledged the violence and hadn’t had the prospect to get out of that story. Why? In actual fact, as a result of the anti-violence facilities had been little identified,” she stated.

“After which as a result of even culturally, girls had been nonetheless very rooted in patriarchal tradition, which is that tradition that’s based mostly on a disparity in energy between women and men, additionally on a relationship dimension of very completely different conceptions of relationships.”

Carelli believes that success evokes different girls. “For us, a girl’s path to freedom can also be necessary for all different girls, as a result of it demonstrates, it’s symbolically consultant of a risk,” she stated. “Girls have the suitable to be free and due to this fact this has a robust worth for us, together with political worth.”

There was a flashpoint final yr when in November, 22-year-old Giulia Cecchettin’s physique was discovered with a number of knife wounds in a ravine in northern Italy per week after being seen along with her ex-boyfriend Filippo Turetta.

Turetta fled to Germany the place he confessed he had killed he lady he nonetheless referred to as his girlfriend although the 2 had been now not collectively.

Cecchettin’s buddies advised investigators that she was involved that Turetta was stalking her. She met him to attempt to defuse the state of affairs, her sister stated.

Turetta is awaiting a fast-track trial that can take note of his confession. He faces as much as life in jail, however will doubtless be given a shorter sentence as a consequence of his confession, based mostly on circumstances with an identical precedent.

Cecchettin’s homicide reignited the controversy on violence in opposition to girls, with large protests held throughout the nation. Greater than 8,000 folks, together with Italy’s president, attended her funeral. However per week after she was buried, 4 extra girls had been useless, all killed by ex-husbands or boyfriends.

Maria Grazia escaped a relationship she describes as abusive.

She advised CNN that she contacted the authorities quite a few occasions, however nobody took her critically.

Girls in Italy who attempt to escape their abusers or worry for his or her lives constantly complain that police are sometimes condescending or accusatory, that someway it’s the sufferer’s fault for upsetting the person, or that they need to simply let him “cool off.”

“There have been threats, steady threats,” Maria Grazia advised CNN.

“Weapons, messages, insults, my intercom was damaged, I wasn’t sleeping at evening.” She stated she hid in her residence with the lights out. She was afraid. “I referred to as the police, who got here, however then requested me, ‘there isn’t any blood?’,” she says. “I replied ‘however when there may be blood I’ll now not want you.’”

When she lastly received away, she and a good friend went on to start out a cooperative referred to as Maison Antigone, which has helped 1000’s of girls navigate an advanced bureaucratic system that usually makes it tough to report abuse.

Typically girls are left to really feel duty for the abuse, she stated.

Her group additionally helps girls work by Italy’s advanced household legislation authorized system to guard youngsters as properly.

Progress is sluggish and infrequently onerous to measure. After Cecchettin’s homicide, the Italian senate handed a unanimous invoice to strengthen protections for girls who’re in danger, or who’ve requested authorities for restraining orders or for abusive companions to be faraway from the house.

“This legislation introduces measures that in lots of circumstances could make the distinction between life and loss of life,” Household Minister Eugenia Roccella stated on the time.

However for a lot of girls the modifications aren’t coming quick sufficient.

“My technology has to coach the technology  to return,” stated Christina, a girl who spoke to CNN. “We’re failing [with] issues I believed would have been gone with my grandparents’ technology.”

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2024 Cable Information Community, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Firm. All rights reserved.

With further reporting from CNN’s Valentina Di Donato.